Former Students Sue Lake Superior College

Updated: 07/16/2014 10:58 PM
Created: 07/16/2014 3:52 PM

16 former students in the Diagnostic Medical Sonography program at Lake Superior College have filed lawsuits against the school. They had hoped to be able to perform ultrasounds as their career. 

But the plaintiffs allege that they cannot continue in that field.

The issue surrounds something called accreditation, which schools earn by proving to an accrediting body they can meet certain national standards.

The lawsuits allege that the school and its staff promised multiple times that they were seeking accreditation and would be accredited, to students in the program. 

In court on Tuesday, an attorney for the plaintiffs said, "We are here because of lies and deceit."

Much of the alleged deceit is related to the instructor, Robert Naughton. For example, the plaintiffs cite a March 2010 email Naughton wrote to a student.

The student initiated the email exchange, according to the lawsuit, and asked Naughton how the accreditation process was going.

Naughton replied, according to the lawsuit, "We have our first site visit from (our accrediting board) in August. If we pass on the first try, we get accredited right away...Hope that helps. Robert." 

When Judge Dale Harris asked about this email in court, the attorney for the school said, "This was an incorrect statement, but we don't think it was maliciously done."

Court documents say that the school did not apply for accreditation until February of 2012. However, the program was suspended in 2013,  the same year Naughton was let go, according to the attorney for the school.

Graduates and former students told Eyewitness News they stayed in the program because of promises that Naughton and other staff made about accreditation. They declined to go on camera, but told us that they were passionate about this career choice.  They told us they feel betrayed because they trusted their instructor, staff, and school to tell them the truth about accreditation and the process of finding work after graduating.

Without the accreditation, they tell us it's nearly impossible to take the certification exam or get the clinical training they need to take the certification exam. Students explained that many health organizations require that graduates come from an accredited school, before they can be hired for clinicals.

The program was around two years of their life, and cost them around $20,000 for tuition, according to plaintiffs and school records.

Gary Halom, an attorney for the plaintiffs told us, "We just want LSC to do the right thing, and deliver an education from an accredited school. We're hoping they will pay to send these people to an accredited school. The four in Minnesota average out to be about $26,000-$28,000. And there's damages each student suffered along the way, including loans and travel."

An attorney for the school said in court on Tuesday that all of the plaintiffs knew the program was not accredited.

Lake Superior College said they do not comment on pending litigation.

A mediation between the two sides is coming up in August.

A trial has been scheduled for November.

Front Page

  • Licenses, Deer Population Down for Wisconsin Deer Opener

    The Wisconsin firearm deer hunting tradition got off to a safe start as Department of Natural Resources officials said they had received no reports of accidental shootings or other injuries by mid-afternoon Sunday on the opener of the state's nine-day gun deer hunt.

  • Northlanders Give Back in Preparation for Holiday Season

    Northlanders gave back on Saturday in preparation for the holiday season. It was Family Volunteer Day at the Duluth Library, and folks participated in several friendly projects.

  • "By Us, For Us" Meeting to Discuss Vision for Equity in Duluth

    Duluth's Native and African heritage communities came together on Saturday to share experiences and ideas at the 1st United Methodist Church. The meeting called "By Us, For Us" invited people of color, African Americans and Native Americans to come together to break bread and learn about each other culturally. 

  • MNsure Enrollments, Renewals Approach 8,000

    Minnesota's health insurance exchange says it has enrolled nearly 8,000 Minnesotans in health plans in the first week of open enrollment this fall. The deadline for enrolling in coverage that takes effect Jan. 1 is Dec. 15.

  • Wisconsin Gun Deer Hunt Begins

    The season opened as the sun rose Saturday and will run through Nov. 30. Forecasts for opening weekend called for freezing rain and fog with highs ranging from the upper 30s to the low 40s both days.


Dense Fog Advisory

MN AREAS AFFECTED: Southern Cook, North Shore; Southern Lake, North Shore
Expires: 11/23/2014 12:00 PM

Dense Fog Advisory

MN AREAS AFFECTED: Carlton, South St. Louis; Crow Wing; North Cass; Northern Aitkin; Pine; South Aitkin; South Cass
Expires: 11/23/2014 12:00 PM

Dense Fog Advisory

WI AREAS AFFECTED: Ashland; Bayfield; Burnett; Douglas; Iron; Price; Sawyer; Washburn
Expires: 11/23/2014 12:00 PM

Winter Storm Watch

Expires: 11/25/2014 8:00 AM