Updated: 05/30/2014 3:11 PM
Created: 05/30/2014 3:08 PM WDIO.com
By: TODD RICHMOND, Associated Press
MADISON, Wis. (AP) - A federal judge said Friday he is worried that a Wisconsin law requiring abortion providers to get hospital admitting privileges is too rigid.
Planned Parenthood and Affiliated Medical Services sued the state last summer, arguing the requirement will force AMS's Milwaukee clinic to close because its doctors can't get admitting privileges.
The groups argue that would amount to restricting access to abortions in Wisconsin. State attorneys say the mandate will ensure continuity of care for women hospitalized with abortion complications.
U.S. District Judge William Conley has put the law on hold while he weighs the issues. Several states have similar laws, including Alabama, Louisiana and Texas. Abortion clinics have challenged Alabama's mandate in a similar lawsuit.
The judge said Friday he was concerned that the law required providers to get privileges within three days of its enactment. Republican Gov. Scott Walker signed the law on July 5, and it required providers to have privileges in place by July 8.
Conley noted that the law provided no grace period and gave abortion providers no recourse if they couldn't get the privileges. He also said it could dampen clinics' efforts to recruit new providers who would essentially have to come to the clinics with admitting privileges in-hand.
"I remain troubled ... with the inflexibility of the law," he said.
The judge didn't immediately rule on the lawsuit and gave both sides time to file additional arguments, meaning a final ruling isn't expected for at least six weeks.
Conley's comments came after he listened to the two sides' last two witnesses.
Stanley Henshaw, a former researcher at the Guttmacher Institute, an abortion rights research organization, testified that AMS is the state's only clinic that performs abortions beyond 19 weeks of pregnancy.
If it closes, Milwaukee women seeking abortions beyond that point in time would have to travel about 85 miles one-way to a clinic in Chicago, he said.
Henshaw, who testified for Planned Parenthood and AMS, said the distance could prevent poor women who lack resources to travel from getting to a clinic.
Closing the AMS facility would leave the state with three abortion clinics, all run by Planned Parenthood. Henshaw said those facilities wouldn't be able to handle the influx of patients who would have otherwise gone to AMS. That would exacerbate appointment delays that already are stretching out as long as a month, he said.
Testifying for the state, University of North Carolina sociologist Peter Uhlenberg argued that Henshaw's opinions were based on reading articles on abortion rates and distance - none of which claim distance prevents abortion.
He said at least some abortion providers in other states with admitting privilege laws have been able to comply.
During the trial on Thursday, the judge told an AMS doctor to renew his efforts to obtain hospital admitting privileges. Conley said it could help resolve the lawsuit short of a decision on the law's constitutionality.
But AMS's attorneys told Conley on Friday that effort would likely be futile. The hospitals want to evaluate the doctor's experience treating abortion patients in a hospital setting, but since abortion complications are so rare he hasn't treated anyone on an in-patient basis for a decade, they said. Still, they said they've already sent letters to every Milwaukee hospital within 30 miles of the AMS facility asking if his clinic experience would qualify.
(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)
Federal Ruling Means No Killing Wolves Unless Endangering Human Life
A federal judge has overturned an Obama administration decision to remove the gray wolf population in the western Great Lakes region from the endangered species list.
Another Round of Budget Cuts at UWS
UWS announced on Friday at an open forum that it will be eliminating academic programs and faculty positions to help to university save money. Four graduate programs and four undergraduate programs will be cut. The university is also severing ties with a music professor and a visual arts professor.
Lake Superior Zoo Reduces Seasonal Hours, Cuts Staff Position
While a task force takes time to consider possible changes to the financially struggling Lake Superior Zoo, there'll be a couple other adjustments in the mean time.
Bigfork Blaze Destroys Home, Injures Firefighter
Firefighters battled the blaze on the 300 block of Ottum Avenue for more than six hours, according to Susie Schmickle with the Bigfork Fire Department.
Prepackaged Caramel Apples Linked to 4 Deaths
Health officials are warning consumers to avoid prepackaged caramel apples after they were linked to five deaths, including two in Minnesota.