Updated: 05/08/2014 7:02 PM
Created: 05/08/2014 4:24 PM WDIO.com
ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) - Stringent standards barring the use of electronic cigarettes in places where regular tobacco isn't allowed prevailed Thursday in the Minnesota Senate, which turned back an attempt to pare down proposed regulations.
The approach endorsed Thursday by a 35-28 margin goes further than a House companion bill, so the two measures must be reconciled for any e-cigarette regulations to become law. It would equate e-cigarettes with standard smokes and classify the new devices under the state's indoor air law.
E-cigarettes are devices that heat a liquid nicotine solution that users inhale, a habit referred to as "vaping." Many former smokers have flocked to them as a way to satisfy a nicotine craving without ingesting tar or exhaling smoke. But some wonder whether the devices keep smokers addicted or hook new users and encourage them to move on to tobacco. Whether vaping has health risks for users or those around them is a source of intense debate.
Aside concerns about scientific unknowns, supporters of the toughest rules said image matters and that allowing e-cigarettes in restaurants, offices and other public spaces normalizes the behavior.
"We should get the message straight and tell kids that smoking is just not right," said Sen. Julie Rosen, R-Fairmont. "I don't care what form it is."
The voted defied party lines, with Republicans and Democrats on both sides of the debate.
Opponents of treating e-cigarettes like other cigarettes said not enough is known about health risks to justify a move to limit their use.
"Where does that end? What are the unknown risks of Cheetos? What are the unknown risks of fried red meat? What are the unknown risks of tap water in St. Paul?" argued Sen. Sean Nienow, R-Cambridge. "There's no end to this logic."
Both House and Senate bills impose restrictions on sales of e-cigarette devices and related liquids to minors. The House bill would also make them off-limits on school property and state government buildings only.
Rep. Laurie Halverson, DFL-Eagan, said the Senate vote makes her hopeful her colleagues will embrace the stronger regulations.
"The use is growing so rapidly, and we're getting so far behind so quickly," she said, adding, "The momentum is there."
The e-cigarette measure is part of a broader health policy bill that, among other things, prohibits anyone under 18 from using tanning beds.
(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)
Smith on Steelworker Layoffs: We are Here to Help
One of Minnesota's top leaders said that they are ready to help the affected workers, who are expecting to be laid off this summer from U.S. Steel.
Four People Rescued From Icy Lake After Trying to Save One Another
Four people were rescued from an icy Spider Lake in Iron River Tuesday night. Deputies say the people went into the water trying to save one another. All four were treated for hypothermia.
Man Pleads Guilty to Killing Mom's Boyfriend in Babbitt
St. Louis County Attorney Mark Rubin says 26-year-old Shawn Doherty pleaded guilty Wednesday to intentional second-degree murder. Doherty admitted that he killed 55-year-old Paul Bulen of Mahtomedi at the home of Doherty's mother in Babbitt on Jan. 13, 2014.
Iron Junction Man Charged with Producing Child Pornography
An Iron Junction man was charged in U.S. District Court on Wednesday with producing child pornography. Sean Penoncello, 41, allegedly took nude pictures of a 7-year-old sometime in September 2012 at his home in rural Cherry.
Northland Job Fair Brings Aisles of Opportunity for 6th Year
The 6th annual Northland Job Fair gave hope to some of the 5.9 percent of Northeastern Minnesotans out of work Wednesday.