Updated: 03/27/2014 10:22 PM
Created: 03/27/2014 4:44 PM WDIO.com
The top prosecutor for Cook County appeared at the defendant's table in Duluth on Thursday.
Tim Scannell was indicted last fall on two counts of criminal sexual conduct. He's accused of sexually touching a 17-year-old girl, who had been a family friend for years. A pivotal part of the case, according to his attorney, is the "position of authority" argument.
Joe Tamburino, Scannell's attorney, said that Scannell was NOT in a position of authority when the alleged touching happened. "He was no longer her tennis coach. Several years BEFORE this, he was."
Tamburino also said, "There's a difference between morality and the law." He's asking the judge to dismiss the indictment, citing evidence issues.
Special Prosecutor on the case, Thomas Heffelfinger, argued extensively that Scannell was in a position of authority over the girl. "There's a laundry list of reasons he was still in a position of authority, including being a coach and asking her to be a co-coach." Heffelfinger said the coaching dates back to when the girl was in the 3rd grade.
Heffelfinger told the court that Scannell lied to the BCA, when he was asked about the touching. He also said that the touching happened in the back of the Scannell family van.
This all came to light when the girl's parents petitioned for and were granted a restraining order against Scannell, in December of 2012. After a lengthy investigation, a grand jury indicted Scannell.
Judge Shaun Floerke said he will rule on the motion to dismiss, in two weeks time.
Several members of Scannell's family were in the courtroom.
According to Cook County officials, Scannell remains on medical leave, although he is in contact with his office staff.
Public Comments on Soo Line Ore Dock's Future
About a month ago, Ashland acquired the Soo Line Ore dock back from the Canadian National Railroad company. On Tuesday, the dock finally opened. They had a "Docks n' Brats" celebration as a way to gain community input for the future of the site.
Minntac in Mt. Iron Waiting for Permits
Senator Al Franken took a tour of the Northland's largest mine on Tuesday. He also pledged to call about a permitting issue that he's weighed in on before. His challenger, Republican Mike McFadden, also weighed in permitting.
Duluth Man Asks City Leaders to Address Memorial Crime
One Duluth Man is asking city leaders for their help in making the Clayton, Jackson, McGhie Memorial a more safe and clean place.
State Will Help Moose Lake Build School If Referendum Passes
It's almost time for kids to head back to school, but in Moose Lake school officials hope their students will be in a new school by 2016. For the fifth time, the school district is asking tax payers to vote yes on a bond referendum this November. The tax hike has been hard to sell in the past, but this year it's a very different story.
Fire Discovered on One of the Apostle Islands
It turns out there's been a fire burning on one of the Apostle Islands for nearly a month, but no one noticed until last week. Park officials believe lightning started the fire in late July, and rain and humid conditions have limited the fire's growth.