Updated: 03/27/2014 10:22 PM
Created: 03/27/2014 4:44 PM WDIO.com
The top prosecutor for Cook County appeared at the defendant's table in Duluth on Thursday.
Tim Scannell was indicted last fall on two counts of criminal sexual conduct. He's accused of sexually touching a 17-year-old girl, who had been a family friend for years. A pivotal part of the case, according to his attorney, is the "position of authority" argument.
Joe Tamburino, Scannell's attorney, said that Scannell was NOT in a position of authority when the alleged touching happened. "He was no longer her tennis coach. Several years BEFORE this, he was."
Tamburino also said, "There's a difference between morality and the law." He's asking the judge to dismiss the indictment, citing evidence issues.
Special Prosecutor on the case, Thomas Heffelfinger, argued extensively that Scannell was in a position of authority over the girl. "There's a laundry list of reasons he was still in a position of authority, including being a coach and asking her to be a co-coach." Heffelfinger said the coaching dates back to when the girl was in the 3rd grade.
Heffelfinger told the court that Scannell lied to the BCA, when he was asked about the touching. He also said that the touching happened in the back of the Scannell family van.
This all came to light when the girl's parents petitioned for and were granted a restraining order against Scannell, in December of 2012. After a lengthy investigation, a grand jury indicted Scannell.
Judge Shaun Floerke said he will rule on the motion to dismiss, in two weeks time.
Several members of Scannell's family were in the courtroom.
According to Cook County officials, Scannell remains on medical leave, although he is in contact with his office staff.
Justin's 2014-2015 Winter Prediction
Winter is right around the corner and the question on everybody's mind is will we have a winter like last year. With record stretches of cold and record snowfall last year is one we one like to forget. Chief meteorologist Justin Liles lets us know what we can expect this year
Woman in Douglas Co. Shootout was found Unresponsive in House Fire Day Before
A 22-year-old Lake Nebagamon woman was hospitalized on Wednesday evening after an armed standoff with the Douglas County Sheriff's Office. On Tuesday, authorities say that same woman was found by her neighbors unresponsive and not breathing after they saw flames coming from a downtown Lake Nebagamon home.
Funding for Military Funeral Personnel Restored
On Thursday, Rep. Rick Nolan received a letter from the Secretary of the Army that funding for the playing of "Taps," a rifle salute, and delivering a folded American flag will be restored.
Preparing for Ebola: Health System Working Together
People who work in the Northland's health system are communicating on a regular basis, to prepare for Ebola, even though it's unlikely to appear here.
St. Luke's Honored by American Heart Association
St. Luke's received three honors from the American Heart Association on Thursday, for their approach and teamwork when taking care of heart and stroke patients.