Updated: 03/26/2014 4:20 PM
Created: 03/26/2014 9:10 AM WDIO.com
By: BRIAN BAKST, Associated Press
ST. PAUL, Minn. (AP) - After Gov. Mark Dayton publicly broke with his Health Department commissioner over the extent of regulation needed on electronic cigarettes, lawmakers took a step Wednesday toward removing a proposed ban on indoor use in public places.
To the dismay of some public health advocates, Dayton came out against legislative efforts to lump e-cigarettes in with conventional cigarettes by barring their use in public buildings and most businesses. His comments directly contradict Health Commissioner Ed Ehlinger's testimony at a Senate committee meeting Monday.
"After we came down pretty hard on smokers last session, that's probably enough for this biennium," Dayton told the Minneapolis Star Tribune, referring to tobacco tax increases last year. "We did enough to smokers last session."
Dayton said he would sign a bill to restrict children's ability to buy e-cigarettes and to keep the product out of schools, but he would likely oppose making them subject to the indoor air law.
A bill that would have done both was awaiting a Senate vote, but it was pulled back to the committee stage where the parts Dayton objected to could be stripped. Sen. Jim Metzen, DFL-South St. Paul, said it made sense to "capitulate a little bit to the governor's wishes and keep the e-cigarette bill alive."
Sen. Kathy Sheran, the bill's sponsor, was startled by the apparent reversal within the administration. She said she would keep pushing for the broader restrictions.
"If there's an instinct that young people should be protected from second-hand vapor, then that instinct should indicate that there should be a reason for protection of the general public, not just youth," said Sheran, DFL-Mankato.
E-cigarettes are thin, cylindrical devices that heat a liquid nicotine solution that users inhale. Unlike regular cigarettes, they don't emit smoke or tar, but there is debate over whether the vapor is clean or laden with chemicals on the way out. The Food and Drug Administration is conducting studies on e-cigarettes but has given no indication when findings will be ready.
At Monday's Senate committee meeting, where the indoor air portion narrowly survived, Ehlinger said the vapor-emitting devices could undermine the state's indoor smoking restrictions and glamorize a habit he believes could lead to a new generation of smokers.
"The state has a responsibility to act on this. This is a threat to the health of the public," Ehlinger, a doctor by training, told the committee, lining up fully behind broad restrictions.
Dayton told the Star Tribune that he's not convinced there is definitive evidence that secondhand vapor poses a danger similar to secondhand smoke.
"Probably everything that you put into the air other than oxygen is some detriment to somebody," the Democratic governor said.
Michael Schommer, a spokesman for Ehlinger, said the health commissioner was "providing input from a public health perspective. The governor's perspective is his own." Schommer said Ehlinger and Dayton were aware of each other's positions, though he declined to say whether the commissioner knowingly took a stance on the administration's behalf that was contrary to the governor's.
Dayton's spokesman, Matt Swenson, issued a statement essentially repeating the governor's comments to the newspaper. Dayton's office had no immediate comment on why the governor and his top health adviser relayed strikingly different positions as the Legislature debates the issue.
House Speaker Paul Thissen, DFL-Minneapolis, said he agrees with the governor on the e-cigarette issue. The House bill includes the crackdown on children's access to the devices and nicotine liquids, while also allowing state government to restrict e-cigarette use in their buildings. Businesses would be free to make their own decisions.
"I don't know this is the year to go beyond that and include e-cigarettes in the entire 'Freedom to Breathe Act,'" Thissen said. "I don't know that the issue is ripe enough now, if we have sufficient information to understand all the implications of it."
E-cigarette sellers have been confronted with attempts in state and local governments to enact new restrictions. Some communities have banned "vaping" in public places. Industry representatives have argued that the devices have been used as substitutes for cigarettes among people trying to quit smoking. They say policymakers should wait for scientific evidence before jumping to conclusion that chemicals involved are unsafe to the users or people in the vicinity.
Some critics contend that rather than helping people quit smoking, e-cigarettes can actually fuel a smoking habit.
Information from: Star Tribune
(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)
Low Gas Prices, Fair Weather Means Smooth Thanksgiving Travel in Northland
The day before Thanksgiving is widely known as the busiest travel day of the year. Travelers were hitting the roads to spend the holiday with friends and family. In addition, gas prices are at the lowest levels of the year
Volunteers Prepare Huge DECC Thanksgiving Feast
Volunteers are preparing 2,400 pounds of turkey, 2,000 pounds of stuffing, and all the other fixings for the DECC's annual Turkey Day feast. It's a chance for hundreds of volunteers to give back.
Duluth Students Collect Thanksgiving Donations for CHUM
Students at St. Michael's School in Duluth have been collecting donations for a Thanksgiving food drive, and on Wednesday they took their donations to CHUM.
Duluth Schools: Working on Purchase Agreement for Central
A buyer has approached the Duluth School District, and wants to purchase the entire former Central High School property.
$1.8M Verdict Upheld in 'American Sniper' Case
A judge has rejected a request from the widow of "American Sniper" author Chris Kyle to order a new trial or toss a jury's verdict in favor of former Minnesota Gov. Jesse Ventura.