Updated: 01/24/2014 6:29 PM
Created: 01/24/2014 5:34 PM WDIO.com
By: Travis Dill
A witness has come forward with new video of the controversial arrest by a Superior police officer earlier this month. The woman arrested has been charged with battery of a peace officer, but her attorney said the new video shows the officer used excessive force.
Video from a police dashboard camera showed how the incident started, but the struggle between 28-year-old Natasha Lancour and Officer George Gothner continued out of view.
Lancour's defense attorney, Rick Gondik, said a witness recorded what happened next, and he said the video shows Gothner continuing to punch his client while she's on her knees.
“This is unequivocally demonstrating that the force was excessive,” Gondik said.
Police reports show Gothner responded to the scene of a fight outside Keyport Lounge in Superior on Jan. 5. The video shows him approaching Lancour and then attempting to arrest her.
Gondik said the cell phone video came from an anonymous witness. He said it fills out the story missing from the previously released police video. He said Gothner was out of line in his use of force.
“He's supposed to be there as a peace officer, as in keep the peace. No he basically initiated this contact, the physical contact, I think that's clear,” Gondik said. “We think this video will demonstrate that this was, in fact, an unlawful use of force.”
Natasha Lancour has been accused of felony battery of Officer Gothner. In his report, Gothner wrote Lancour resisted arrest and reached up and scratched his face so he responded with two closed fist punches. Gondik said the punches were unjustified whether or not his client scratched Gothner.
“The proportionality, the level of force leveled on her was way out of proportion to a scratch,” Gondik said.
Superior Police also received the anonymous video on Friday, and officials said it was placed into evidence. Police have sent it to the independent investigator reviewing Gothner's use of force.
Chief Charles LaGesse said he had no comment on the new video, but in a Wednesday interview LaGesse said the case will be resolved in court.
“This is a case that will be tried in criminal court, and potentially in civil court, and that's where it should be tried. And I'm not trying it in the media by making further comment,” LaGesse said.
Superior Police said Gothner has been moved to office duty and will not be on patrol until the investigation is complete. However LaGesse emphasized that the change is not a disciplinary action.
Superior Murder Trial Delayed after New Evidence Released
Juan Leonardo Padilla, 40, of Fort Mohave, Ariz., is charged with the shooting death of 46-year-old Terrance Rodney Luukkonen of Duluth last May. Luukkonen was shot outside his workplace at Genesis Attachments in Superior.
Homemade Audio Unveiled During Day 2 of Byron Smith Murder Trial
It was a homemade recording inside Byron Smith's home. The hand held device was next to Smith's chair during the shootings. Smith didn't turn it over to police, or even tell them about it. Investigators found the evidence while searching Smith's home the day after the shootings. Although it was 6 hours long, 14 minutes of the audio clip were played in court Tuesday.
Construction to Begin on Last Major St. Louis County Road Damaged by 2012 Floods
While the devastating floods of 2012 may be a distant memory for some, there are still some visible scars left - including on one western Duluth road. 57th Avenue West and Highland Street is the last major St. Louis County road still damaged by the flooding.
Duluth School Board Approves Plan to Help Sell Central High
One of Duluth's most scenic vantage points - the Central High School property, has been up for sale for most of four years, but still sits empty. On Tuesday night, school and city leaders took a step to do something about that: a formal working arrangement has been made.
Minn. Clergy Members, Doctors Voice Support for Medical Marijuana Legalization
Medical marijuana is a hotly-debated issue this session, and on Tuesday more than 100 doctors and clergy members headed to the Minnesota State Capitol to show their support for its legalization. The group includes representatives from the Minnesota Nurses Association, Minnesota AIDS Project, AFL-CIO, and the United Food and Commercial Workers union.