Scannell Testifies in His Own Criminal Sexual Misconduct Trial

Updated: 07/23/2014 7:33 PM
Created: 07/23/2014 5:32 PM
By: Briggs LeSavage

Cook County Attorney Tim Scannell took the witness stand today for what was an emotional testimony from the man charged with two accounts of 4th degree criminal sexual misconduct for a relationship he allegedly had with a 17-year old girl in August 2012. 

The defense questioned him for nearly two hours about his alleged relationship with the now 19-year old girl, the Cook County community and the courthouse shooting that nearly took his life in December 2011. 

While his attorney Joe Tamburino was questioning him, Scannell said he was the girl's tennis and soccer coach, guitar teacher and family friend. He said this level of involvement with kids other than his own two sons wasn't unusual for him.

"Before I got shot, I was kind of like the Cook County mentor," Scannell said. 

He testified that he never had romantic feelings for the girl until one day in spring 2012 when he was helping her with college applications. Scannell said he told her he was attracted to her and that he couldn't help her anymore. 

On a trip to the Twin Cities to visit family friends and watch a tennis tournament on June 8, 2012, Scannell said he was alone with the girl in his car on his way to pick up his son from the airport. He testified that he told her again that he was attracted to her. 

"She put her hand on the console, and I thought 'Should I touch her hand?" Scannell testified today. He said they then interlaced pinky fingers and he put her hand on her neck as he told her about his feelings. 

During this conversation, both Scannell and his sister, Tara Scannell, testified that he accidentally called her on his cell phone. Tara Scannell overhead the conversation her brother was having with the girl. 

It was that night after he learned his sister had heard the conversation that Scannell said contemplated suicide. 

"I slept not one wink ... I thought variously about running out into traffic and killing myself."

Scannell said he called his wife the next day and told her about his feelings for the girl. He said his wife reacted calmly, saying they would work through the situation and get help.

"I am graced by (my wife's) presence in my life," Scannell said. 

After an episode weeks later, Scannell said he was hospitalized at a psychiatric ward and he did not speak to the teenage girl for some time. Weeks later, he said they began talking again, and he said he would see her at her work. 

Scannell said one time in summer 2012 he was at her work, and the girl suggested they go for a drive on her break. 

He said they talked about his feelings toward her and "how being with her was the only thing that was keeping me from jumping off a cliff."

Scannell said he and the girl began going for drives more frequently. On the stand, he recalled the first time they kissed on one of their drives. Before they left for that drive, Scannell testified he remembered thinking "this is a really bad idea." 

Scannell said it became routine to meet at a particular road outside of Grand Marais, and that he and the girl would often meet each other at the location in separate vehicles. 

"I think we got into a vehicle and kissed less than 10 times," Scannell said. 

Tamburino asked Scannell about the allegations that he touched the girl's breasts during one of these meetings. Scannell said he could remember a time when he accidentally "leaned over and brushed her breasts." Scannell said the girl then laughed and said that can't happen. Scannell said he knew what he was doing was wrong. 

"She's too young. I'm too old If anyone finds out, we're going to get into a scandal," Scannell testified Wednesday.

Tamburino did not question Scannell about the girl's testimony Tuesday that alleged Scannell asked the girl to have sexual intercourse with him.

After the girl's parents learned about the relationship on Sept. 25, 2012, they asked Scannell to stay away from their daughter. The girl was studying in Spain, but Scannell said the texting and emailing continued by the girl's request as well as his interest while he was receiving treatment at a rehabilitation center in Arizona. The girl's parents filed a restraining order in December 2012.

The prosecution also called Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension Investigator John Nordberg to the stand Wednesday. Nordberg said he recovered many documents showing communication between the girl and Scannell after serving Facebook, Apple, Google and LinkedIn with search warrants.

Nordberg said the investigators had wanted to speak with the girl after the restraining order was filed. On Jan, 29, 2013, Nordberg said they had still not spoken with her, so they sent a letter to her family. On Feb. 28, 2013, investigators had their first meeting with the girl.

Molly Hicken, the assistant Cook County attorney, also testified Wednesday and recalled her experience with the courthouse shooting as well as about a dozen conversations she had with Scannell about his relationship with the girl.

Scannell will be cross examined Thursday morning. Judge Shaun Floreke said he plans to have all testimonies completed by the end of the day. 

Front Page

  • Police Replace Two Children's Toys Lost in Fire

    The Easter Sunday blaze that destroyed the Applewood Knoll apartments in Duluth was also the last time two children saw the toys the treasured, so on Saturday morning, members of the Duluth Police Department took those kids on a shopping trip, hoping the gesture would help them move forward....

  • Twin Ports Food Activists Host Rally Against Monsanto

    Support for local and healthy foods was the focus of a rally on Saturday in the Twin Ports. The event on the corner of Lake Avenue and Superior Street featured local farmers showcasing their plants and produce and talking to the public about sustainable agriculture...

  • Kids Channel Inner Poet at Poet-Tree Event

    Children were able to explore the beauty of poetry and trees at an event sponsored by the Duluth Library Foundation as well as other organizations.


  • Dayton Vetoes Agriculture-Environment and Jobs-Energy Bills

    Gov, Mark Dayton vetoed two major budget bills ahead of a Saturday night deadline for final action on bills that passed before the end of the legislative session, adding to the workload that lawmakers will face in an upcoming special session.

  • Northlanders Gear Up for Memorial Day Weekend Travel

    Campers and boats filled Highway 61 Friday afternoon enroute to Memorial Daynweekend destinations up the North Shore. Trip Adviser said Friday is the busiest day for travel over the holiday weekend where 41 percent of Americans said they had trips planned....


Flood Warning

MN AREAS AFFECTED: Crow Wing; Morrison
Expires: 5/24/2015 9:00 AM