abc
QUICK LINKS:

Wisconsin Judge Clarifies Abortion Law

Updated: 07/17/2014 3:37 PM
Created: 07/17/2014 2:04 PM WDIO.com
By: SCOTT BAUER, Associated Press

MADISON, Wis. (AP) - A Dane County circuit court judge ruled Thursday that doctors do not have to be present when a woman takes drugs prescribed for a medical abortion, a decision that allows the practice to continue in Wisconsin.

Both abortion provider Planned Parenthood and the state Department of Justice had agreed on how the law ought to be interpreted, and Judge Richard Niess concurred. The law had been on hold since April 2013 while the case, which began in federal court but was moved to state court because of jurisdictional issues, was pending.

Niess said in his ruling that doctors have to be present when giving the drug to a woman, but they do not have to be there when the woman actually ingests the pill.

Republican Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen, who defended the law, said the ruling is in line with what his office always interpreted it to mean.

"No one ever tried to enforce the law differently," he said in a statement. "Planned Parenthood's case was a frivolous action from the beginning"

But Planned Parenthood attorney Lester Pines said the lawsuit was necessary to prevent anti-abortion district attorneys from going after doctors who distribute the pills but aren't present when they are ingested.

The Republican-controlled Legislature passed the law in 2012 and Gov. Scott Walker, an abortion opponent, signed it into law. Sen. Mary Lazich, a Republican who sponsored the bill, had no immediate comment on the ruling.

The law mandates that women having nonsurgical abortions visit the same doctor three times and that the doctor must ensure the woman is having the procedure voluntarily and without coercion. Failure to follow those requirements could result in felony charges against the doctor.

Niess said in his ruling that as long as doctors make good-faith efforts to determine that women seeking abortions were voluntarily consenting to the procedure, they can't face penalties if it turns out the woman had been coerced into getting an abortion.

Niess lifted the hold he put on the law last year and declined to issue an order permanently blocking the law.

The law bars Internet consultations, a practice used in other states but not Wisconsin.

The law does not affect emergency contraception, known as the morning-after pill.

Planned Parenthood initially stopped medical abortions at its clinics in Madison, Milwaukee and the Appleton area due to confusion over whether a doctor could be subject to criminal penalties if he or she is not present when the patient ingests the pill.

Those resumed when the law was put on hold last year and will continue, said Pines, the Planned Parenthood attorney.

"Planned Parenthood doctors are following the law," he said.

Teri Huyck, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood of Wisconsin, called the ruling a "victory for women and their ability to decide which medical procedure is best for their own health and circumstances."

"The decision recognizes that medical professionals should be trusted to determine the safest and best medical care for their patients," she said.

A separate lawsuit in federal court, also brought by Planned Parenthood, challenges a different state law requiring doctors performing abortions to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals. The judge put that law on hold pending his ruling in a trial that ended in May.

(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

Front Page

  • Woman Hospitalized after Armed Standoff with Deputies in Douglas County

    A 22-year-old Lake Nebagamon woman was hospitalized on Wednesday evening after an armed standoff with the Douglas County Sheriff's Office. 

  • City of Tower Starts Dredging on Multi-Million-Dollar Harbor Project

    The City of Tower is starting a new phase of an old dream. Back in June, WDIO's sister station KSTP reported that Tower's multi-million-dollar Harbor Renaissance Project hadn't gone anywhere in seven years. But Wednesday, the City said they're moving forward.

  • Minnesota Food Charter Launched at DECC

    Around five hundred people flocked to the DECC for the Minnesota Statewide Food Access Summit. One of the big events? The launch of the of the Minnesota Food Charter. Only four other states have a food charter, but Food Charter Steering Committee Chair Mindy Kurzer said number five is unique.

  • Bong Bridge to Reopen Friday

    The Duluth-bound lanes of the Richard I. Bong Bridge are expected to reopen Friday morning after a summer of construction.  Superior-bound lanes have remained open this year but will be closed next year.

  • TV Campaign Ads Make Wealth an Issue in Minn. Election

    It seems an hour doesn't go by without several television campaign ads criticizing a candidate for having millions of dollars or trying to line his or her pockets at government expense. Class warfare is nothing new in politics, but it certainly is more pronounced in Minnesota this year because of two Republican candidates: Stewart Mills and Mike McFadden. They've been the target of a barrage of attack ads aimed at their personal wealth and how they accumulated it.

 

Lake Effect Snow Advisory

WI AREAS AFFECTED: Iron
Expires: 10/31/2014 11:00 AM

Lake Effect Snow Advisory

MI AREAS AFFECTED: Gogebic; Houghton; Keweenaw; Ontonagon; Southern Houghton
Expires: 10/31/2014 12:00 PM

Lakeshore Flood Advisory

MI AREAS AFFECTED: Alger; Baraga; Gogebic; Houghton; Keweenaw; Marquette; Ontonagon
Expires: 10/31/2014 2:00 PM

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement