abc
QUICK LINKS:

FDA Wants Stricter Safety Rules for Pelvic Mesh

Updated: 04/29/2014 4:31 PM
Created: 04/29/2014 11:21 AM WDIO.com
By: MATTHEW PERRONE, AP Health Writer

WASHINGTON (AP) - Makers of trouble-prone implants used to surgically repair women's pelvic problems would be subject to stricter safety requirements under a federal proposal issued Tuesday.

The Food and Drug Administration says plastic mesh used to repair pelvic collapse should be reclassified as a "high-risk" medical device, following years of reports of pain, bleeding and infection among women who have received the implants. If adopted, the change would require manufacturers to submit studies demonstrating that their products are safe and effective before they can be sold.

Plastic mesh has been used since the late 1990s to strengthen the pelvic wall in cases of pelvic organ prolapse, in which the bladder or other reproductive organs slip down into the vagina. The condition is common among older women and those who've had children. The most common technique for implanting the mesh involves a surgical insertion through the vagina.

The FDA's proposal comes nearly three years after the agency first concluded that women getting the mesh have more complications than women who undergo traditional surgery with stitches. An agency analysis found that 10 percent of women experienced mesh erosion within 12 months, meaning their mesh had worn its way through the vaginal wall into the surrounding tissue or organs. More than half of these women required follow-up surgery to remove the mesh - sometimes two or more procedures.

Mesh products were initially pitched to doctors as a high-tech improvement over surgery, but the FDA found no evidence that they improve safety outcomes.

"The FDA has identified clear risks associated with surgical mesh for the transvaginal repair of pelvic organ prolapse and is now proposing to address those risks for more safe and effective products," said William Maisel, chief scientist for the FDA's device center.

The FDA proposal does not apply to mesh products used to treat incontinence, hernia and other conditions not related to women's health.

The first pelvic mesh products for women received fast-track approval from the FDA because they were deemed similar to mesh long used to treat hernias. At the time the FDA classified all pelvic mesh as a "moderate-risk," device, not subject to the rigorous testing of high-risk implants. Under Tuesday's proposal, companies would have to submit clinical data establishing their devices' safety for pelvic collapse before gaining FDA approval. The agency will take comments on the plan for 90 days.

Injuries caused by mesh for pelvic collapse are the subject of more than 22,000 personal injury lawsuits against leading manufacturer Johnson & Johnson.

Women suing the company allege that New Brunswick, N.J.-based J&J was aware of the risks of its product but did not warn the public.

Gay Courter of Crystal River, Fla., said she was "heartened" by news that the FDA plans to reclassify the devices.

"We look to the FDA to protect women because corporations who profit from these products have not responsibly done long-term testing or reporting of adverse events," said Courter, one of several mesh patients who spoke against J&J at its annual shareholders meeting last week.

J&J spokeswoman Sheri Woodruff said in a statement late Tuesday that J&J stopped selling its pelvic prolapse mesh products in 2012, "in light of changing market dynamics." The company continues to sell mesh to treat stress urinary incontinence, which causes bladder leaks.

Woodruff said those devices "are considered by many to be the gold standard of treatment" for incontinence.

(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

Front Page

  • St. Louis County Follows National Rise in Female Incarceration

    The number of women behind bars in the U.S. is rising at an alarming rate: nearly double the increases seen for male incarceration. While the number of incarcerated women in this country is still significantly less than men, but it's a 646 percent increase in women behind bars over the last 30 years that's turning heads.

  • UMD Professor Getting National Recognition for Research

    Professor Byron Steinman is in his second semester at UMD, but he is already making a big impression. Steinman has been working over a year on the causes of climate change, and his recent work is getting published in Science Magazine. Furthermore, it is getting some national attention, including from U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.).

  • Gogebic Taconite Suspends Investments, Closes Hurley Office

    Blaming regulatory uncertainty, Gogebic Taconite has suspended investments in its proposed northern Wisconsin mine and closed its office in Hurley, leaving four people without jobs and raising questions about whether the mine will ever be built.

  • Minnesota's Anticipated Surplus Swells to $1.87 Billion

    Minnesota's bank account is projected to run up a $1.87 billion surplus over the next two years, which will drive calls for new spending, tax cuts or most likely a mix.  The surplus is substantially more than the $1 billion estimated in December.

  • Middle Schoolers Tackle Ice Fishing on St. Louis River

    Middle school students from St. James School put their lessons into practice on Friday. They have been studying ice fishing in their life science curriculum this year, thanks to funding from a STEM grant.

 
Advertisement