abc
QUICK LINKS:

Users Bemoan E-cigarette Bans in NYC, Chicago

Updated: 04/29/2014 9:55 AM
Created: 04/29/2014 9:14 AM WDIO.com
By: MICHAEL R. SISAK, Associated Press

NEW YORK (AP) - Laws in New York and Chicago making electronic cigarettes subject to the same regulations as tobacco are taking effect, and their sellers and users are steadfast in their opposition.

The New York ban - along with the measure in Chicago, one that previously went into effect in Los Angeles and federal regulations proposed last week - are keeping debate smoldering among public health officials, the e-cigarette industry and users.

Proponents of the bans which began Tuesday say they are aimed at preventing the re-acceptance of smoking as a societal norm, particularly among teenagers who could see the tobacco-free electronic cigarettes, with their candy-like flavorings and celebrity endorsers, as a gateway to cancer-causing tobacco products.

Dr. Thomas Farley, the New York City health commissioner under former Mayor Michael Bloomberg, says allowing electronic cigarettes in bars and restaurants would undermine existing bans on tobacco-based products.

"Imagine for a moment you're at a bar and there are 20 people who are puffing on something that looks like a cigarette and then somebody smells something that smells like tobacco smoke," Farley says. "How's the bartender going to know who to tap on the shoulder and say, 'Put that out'?"

Makers of the devices say marketing them as e-cigarettes has confused lawmakers into thinking they are the same as tobacco-based cigarettes. They say the bans ostracize people who want an alternative to tobacco products and will be especially hard on ex-smokers who are being lumped into the same smoking areas as tobacco users.

Their defenders also say they're a good way to quit tobacco, even though science is murky on the claim.

Peter Denholtz, the chief executive and co-founder of the Henley Vaporium in Manhattan, says electronic cigarettes "could be the greatest invention of our lifetime in terms of saving lives" by moving smokers away from traditional cigarettes.

"This law just discourages that," he says.

Chris Jehly, a 31-year-old Brooklyn resident, also defended the devices as a vehicle for quitting.

"The tougher they're going to make it on vapers, the tougher it is people are going to find an actual vehicle for quitting or as a supplement to cigarettes," Jehly said from his perch at the counter at Henley. "There's no need for it. This is working so much better than patches or gum or prescription drugs."

Robin Koval, chief executive of the anti-smoking Legacy Foundation, said that while ingredients in electronic cigarettes are not as harmful as those in tobacco products, they are still a concern because they contain highly addictive nicotine. The National Institutes of Health said users could expose themselves to toxic levels of nicotine while refilling the devices or even use them to smoke other substances.

Since little evidence exists on the effect of the devices on smoking - whether as an aid in quitting, a gateway for non-smokers or a bridge to keep smokers hooked longer - she says she favors a legislative approach that balances public health with the development of safer alternatives.

"The right way forward will be a way that promotes innovation that helps us do everything we possibly can to get combustible tobacco to be history," Koval says. "We want a generation of Americans where, for them, cigarettes are a thing of the past - an artifact like a roll of film or a rotary telephone."

(Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

Front Page

  • Hennepin Co. Prosecutor Files Petition to Protect Adrian Peterson's Son

    The Minnesota Vikings star running back was charged with a felony in Texas for using a wooden switch to spank his son while he was visiting Peterson's home in May. Peterson said he was using a form of discipline his father used on him as a boy.

  • 29 Interested in Growing Minnesota Medical Pot

    The Minnesota Department of Health says it has received 29 letters of intent from people interested in growing medical marijuana under the state's new program.

  • Balloons were able to inflate in 2013, but could not take off.  Organizers are hopeful for better weather conditions this year. Balloon Festival Underway in Bayfront Park

    If the weather cooperates, something that hasn't happened for more than a century in Duluth could happen this weekend.  If not, visitors to "Le Festival des Montgolfieres a Duluth" will still be able to enjoy numerous free family activities.

  • Ironwood Man Convicted of Child Enticement

    An Ironwood man has pleaded no contest to a felony child enticement charge after allegedly traveling to a northern Wisconsin community to meet what he thought was a 15-year-old girl.

  • Poll: Support for PolyMet Mine Has Declined

    A new poll shows support for a proposed copper and nickel mine in northeastern Minnesota has declined. The poll for the Star Tribune shows 40 percent of Minnesotans surveyed approve of PolyMet's plans.

 
Advertisement