Created: 11/18/2013 3:11 PM WDIO.com
By: MARILYNN MARCHIONE, AP Chief Medical Writer
DALLAS (AP) - New research raises serious questions about a very common medical procedure - placing a stent to prop open a narrowed kidney artery. A study found that people treated with these stents plus various heart drugs fared no better than people treated with medicines alone.
"Doctors are doing this procedure in the absence of good clinical evidence" and that should stop, at least for patients like those in this study, said Dr. Robert Harrington. He is a Stanford University cardiologist and program chief for the American Heart Association's scientific conference, where the study was discussed on Monday.
Stents are tiny mesh scaffolds pushed into narrowed, hardened arteries to help keep them open. They are widely used and known to help treat clogged heart arteries, but their value for some other types of blood vessels is less clear.
Narrowed kidney arteries plague 1 to 5 percent of people with high blood pressure, and as many as 7 percent of all people over age 65.
The problem can cause high blood pressure or make it worse, which raises the risk of heart attacks, strokes and kidney failure.
Stents seemed to be a reasonable thing to try to keep blood flowing to the kidneys, and at least 40,000 of these operations are done each year in the United States alone. Two previous studies surprisingly found no benefit, but many doctors disregarded those results because the patients had relatively mild blockages.
The new study tested stents in people who had lost more than half of the normal diameter of the artery because of built-up plaque in the blood vessel's wall.
Dr. Christopher Cooper of the University of Toledo and others around the country gave nearly 1,000 patients stents plus a combination of heart drugs or medicines alone. Nearly four years later, about 35 percent of both groups had experienced a heart attack, stroke, hospitalization for heart problems, death from heart or kidney disease or needed dialysis because of failing kidneys.
The result "establishes beyond a reasonable doubt" that stents are futile for people like those in this study, Dr. John Bittl of Munroe Regional Medical Center in Ocala, Fla., writes in an editorial published online with the study in the New England Journal of Medicine.
The particular combination of drugs used in the study proved better than expected, and patients were given them for free, which helped ensure they were taken, he noted.
Stents "seemed to be a reasonable approach," but the new study casts strong doubt on that, Harrington said.
(Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)
Special Report: Pattie's Journey
A local woman shares her journey in the fight against breast cancer. She's sharing the struggle of letting go of what she can't control and reclaiming what cancer strips away.
Nolan Bill Requires 'Buy American Steel' in Pipeline Projects
A bill introduced by Congressman Rick Nolan would require American made steel, made with American made iron ore pellet, to be used in virtually all pipeline projects.
E-Cigarette Business Booming as FDA Proposes New Regulations
Regulating the sale and use of electronic cigarettes is the goal of new rules proposed by the Food and Drug Administration Thursday. If approved, e-cigarette sales would be banned to people under age 18, a warning label would be placed on the devices, and manufacturers would be required to tell the FDA what's in their products.
Advocates Push for More Affordable Housing in Minn.
Housing advocates are pushing Minnesota lawmakers to do more to help low-income renters. Sherman Associates' renovation of the old Lincoln Park Middle School will provide 50 new housing units for Duluth next year. But researchers with the progressive think tank Minnesota 2020 say more needs to be done.
Hermantown Cheerleaders: We Just Want to Cheer
The Hermantown cheer team is fighting back after they learned the school board had approved to cut their district funding last week. The cut is part of larger budget cuts, but the cheerleaders are picketing Friday and Monday in hopes of gaining support at the next school board meeting. Whether school-funded or self-funded, the girls just want to cheer.