abc
QUICK LINKS:

Experts Defend New Heart Attack Prevention Advice

Updated: 11/18/2013 1:36 PM
Created: 11/18/2013 11:47 AM WDIO.com
By: MARILYNN MARCHIONE, AP Chief Medical Writer

DALLAS (AP) - Heart experts who wrote new guidelines for preventing heart attacks and strokes are defending a formula that some doctors say overestimates risk for certain groups.

Doctors who drafted the new advice for the American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology say that any flaws in the formula are small and should not delay the implementation of the guidelines, which expand how many people should consider taking cholesterol-lowering statin drugs like Lipitor and Zocor or their generic forms.

The guidelines, announced last week, are a sea change in heart care. Instead of having people aim for a specific cholesterol number as has been done for decades, the new advice relies on a formula using factors such as age and high blood pressure to estimate a patient's risk.

Under the new advice, one-third of U.S. adults ages 40 to 75 would meet the threshold to consider taking a statin. Under the current guidelines, statins are recommended for only about 15 percent of this group.

The Heart Association held a news briefing Monday at its annual conference in Dallas after a New York Times story featured criticism by several prominent cardiologists.

Dr. Paul Ridker and Dr. Nancy Cook of Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston describe in an opinion piece in the British journal Lancet how they tried the formula on patients in three large, observational clinical trials and found it was way off for the number of heart attacks and strokes those patients actually had.

"The predicted risk is roughly twice as high as the observed risk," Ridker said.

However, doctors involved in the guidelines said one reason there were so few of those health problems is that the patients in those studies were prescribed statins to lower their risk.  And the groups in the studies Ridker cited were much healthier than Americans in general.

"This tool does an excellent job of ranking people," Dr. David Goff, dean of the Colorado School of Public Health, said of the risk formula his panel developed.

Dr. Sidney C. Smith Jr., a former Heart Association president from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, said dozens of heart experts spent nearly five years carefully reviewing top-quality studies to develop the guidelines and the formula and let other major medical groups review it before adopting it.

"We think that we've come up with a good risk instrument" and intend to move forward to implement the guidelines, he said. The formula doesn't prescribe or mandate that someone take a drug, just flag people whose heart risks are high enough that they should consider it.

"You should have that conversation with your physician. This is not computer medicine," Smith said.

Even Ridker calls the guidelines a big improvement and says the risk formula problems should be easy to address. The guidelines are the first that aim to prevent strokes and heart attacks and customize risk assessment for women versus men and blacks versus whites.

High cholesterol leads to hardened arteries that can cause a heart attack or stroke, and heart disease is the leading cause of death worldwide.

"This is a huge burden in our society and we have to be able to bend that curve," said Dr. Donald Lloyd-Jones, a Northwestern University cardiologist who helped lead the guideline effort.

Some doctors don't like the guidelines for reasons that have nothing to do with the risk formula.

Dr. Daniel Rader of the University of Pennsylvania said the older guidelines made it easier for doctors and patients to determine risk, by relying on specific cholesterol numbers.

"I do think it was a mistake to move away from targets" for cholesterol, he said.

___

Online:

(Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

Front Page

  • Authorities Investigating Possible Homicide on the Fond Du Lac Reservation

    Authorities are investigating the death of a 31-year-old woman in Stoney Brook Township on the Fond Du Lac Reservation. The St. Louis County Sheriff's Office said Monday that they believe the death was an act of violence. One suspect has been taken into custody and authorities are asking for the public's help locating a woman who may have more information.

  • No Criminal Charges for Superior Officer in Controversial Arrest

    Superior Police Chief Charles F. LaGesse announced Monday morning the Bayfield County District Attorney has issued his decision about the actions of Officer George Gothner during the arrest of Natasha Lancour.

  • Crash Survivor Shares Story To Fight Distracted Driving

    An Itasca County woman took the stage at Proctor High School Monday to share her story and raise awareness about the dangers of distracted driving. Paige Anderson was in an accident five years ago when the car she was in was hit by a bus. She's paralyzed from the stomach down and in a wheelchair.

  • Proctor Police Searching for Suspect in Armed Robbery

    The Proctor Police Department is asking for the public's help in their search for the suspect from an armed robbery Sunday night. They say the suspect robbed the Proctor Milk House at gunpoint at about 10:15 p.m.

  • Early Voting Begins in Wisconsin

    Municipal clerks across Wisconsin began accepting ballots Monday. Early voting hours generally run from 8 a.m. until 7 p.m. weekdays, however local clerks can set their own hours within those perimeters. Early voting ends Oct. 31.

 
Advertisement